Shadow Work

The Phrase Jung Never Used

First attested
1986Robert Bly, A Little Book on the Human Shadow, edited with an introduction by William Booth — first published by Raccoon Books, Memphis, 1986, and reprinted by Harper & Row, San Francisco, 1988 (81 pp.), which is the edition that circulated. It contains "The long bag we drag behind us" and "Five stages in exiling, hunting, and retrieving the shadow", and is the text in which the Jungian sense of the practice is assembled; whether Bly uses the compound "shadow work" in it is unverified. The phrase itself is older: Ivan Illich's Shadow Work (Marion Boyars, 1981), in an unrelated economic sense.
Claimed
1951asserted by The self-help literature from 1986 onward and its publishers, who present the exercises as Jung's own practice; Jung's fullest treatment of the shadow is Aion, published in German in 1951.

"Shadow work" is not a phrase Jung used — it assembles from Robert Bly's 1986 A Little Book on the Human Shadow onward and becomes a genre with the 1991 anthology Meeting the Shadow; and Aion §19, the chapter the market invokes, calls the archetypal shadow the hardest case of all, where owning one's relative evil is possible but facing absolute evil is rare and shattering.

Named for Jung's shadow and sold as a practice he never described, to be done in a notebook.

Jung treated the shadow most fully in chapter two of Aion (German 1951; Hull's English 1959): §14 grants that the personal shadow yields only to considerable moral effort, §19 that as an archetype it is another matter — a man may own his relative evil, but gazing into absolute evil is rare and shattering. The compound is not his. Ivan Illich had printed Shadow Work in 1981, meaning unpaid domestic labour. The Jungian sense assembles in the American men's movement: Robert Bly's A Little Book on the Human Shadow (Raccoon Books, 1986; Harper & Row, 1988), with its long bag and five stages; then Zweig and Abrams's Meeting the Shadow (Tarcher, 1991); then Debbie Ford's The Dark Side of the Light Chasers (Riverhead, 1998), a bestseller after Oprah Winfrey took it up in 2000. By 2021 it is a fill-in journal.

Light

Bly's five stages are a method rather than a mood: he asks the reader to read what he cannot stand in others as his own exiled material. Zweig and Abrams put Jung, von Franz and Hillman into a paperback a general reader could buy.

Shadow

A notebook offers Aion's hardest case: §19 grants a man his relative evil, but facing absolute evil is rare and shattering. Jung sited the shadow's stubbornness in projection (§§16-17), where the cause seems to lie in the other person — which a solitary worksheet removes.

Sources and verification8 sources · 5 links

Primary source

  • C. G. Jung, trans. R. F. C. Hull, Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self, Collected Works 9ii, 1951, ch. II "The Shadow", §§13-19; esp. §14, §§16-17 and §19 (German 1951; Hull's English 1959)That Jung distinguishes a personal shadow, which becomes conscious only through considerable moral effort (§14), from features that resist because they are carried by projection (§§16-17), and from the shadow met as an archetype (§19), where a man may still recognise his relative evil but gazing into absolute evil is 'a rare and shattering experience'. Jung does not say the archetypal shadow cannot be integrated.
  • Ivan Illich, Shadow Work, 1981, Marion Boyars, London and Boston; Ideas in Progress seriesThat the phrase "shadow work" was in print five years before Bly, in an unrelated sense: the unpaid labour an industrial economy requires of households.
  • Robert Bly, ed. William Booth, A Little Book on the Human Shadow, 1986, First edition Raccoon Books, Memphis, 1986, edited with an introduction by William Booth; reprinted Harper & Row, San Francisco, 1988, 81 pp. — chapters "The long bag we drag behind us" and "Five stages in exiling, hunting, and retrieving the shadow"The point at which the American men's-movement literature turns Jung's shadow into something to be worked on, with the long bag as its image and a five-stage sequence as its procedure. The 1988 Harper & Row reprint is the edition that circulated.
  • Connie Zweig and Jeremiah Abrams (eds), Meeting the Shadow: The Hidden Power of the Dark Side of Human Nature, 1991, J. P. Tarcher, Los Angeles; ISBN 0-87477-618-X; opens with Bly's "The long bag we drag behind us"That the subject becomes a genre in 1991, in an anthology of some sixty-five essays that prints Jung, Marie-Louise von Franz and James Hillman alongside popular writers.
  • Debbie Ford, The Dark Side of the Light Chasers: Reclaiming Your Power, Creativity, Brilliance, and Dreams, 1998, Riverhead Books, New York; ISBN 1-57322-096-5The mass-market form of the practice; the book reached the New York Times list after Oprah Winfrey discussed it in late 2000.

Scholarship

  • Wouter J. Hanegraaff, New Age Religion and Western Culture, 1996, Brill / SUNYThe psychologisation of esoteric material in the twentieth century — the general mechanism by which a clinical construct becomes a self-help technique.
  • Christopher Partridge, The Re-Enchantment of the West, vol. 1, 2004, T&T Clark"Occulture" — Partridge's term for the reservoir through which an esoteric motif reaches a mass audience with no lineage, initiation or transmission attached to it.

Where this claim originates

  • Alexandra Alter, "How a Self-Published Book, 'The Shadow Work Journal,' Became a Best Seller", The New York Times, 2024, 30 May 2024The 2020s form: Keila Shaheen's journal, self-published in 2021 and distributed largely through TikTok Shop before Simon & Schuster reissued it in April 2024.

Linked entries

  • Derives fromThe ShadowAttested

    The genre takes its name and its authority from Jung's shadow, and specifically from the Aion chapter whose §19 calls facing absolute evil rare and shattering — a difficulty the genre does not mention.

  • Set againstIndividuationAttested

    Jung defined individuation in Psychological Types (1921) as the opposite of individualism, and held separately that it is unsuitable for the young and proper to the second half of life; the market sells shadow work as self-improvement, to anyone, at any age.

  • Corrected byThe Archetype and the Archetypal ImageAttested

    The market phrase treats the shadow as an object that can be inventoried and worked through; on Jung's distinction only images are ever available to consciousness, so whatever an exercise handles is an archetypal image and not the archetype.

  • Set againstThe Word ArchetypeA modern connection

    The borrowing runs the other way here: "archetype" is an ancient word Jung gave a new sense, while "shadow work" is a recent phrase Jung never used that travels under his name.

  • Corrected byThe ShadowAttested

    Integration is Jung's own word - Aion §42 makes 'the integration of the shadow' the first stage of the analytic process - so the correction is not to the word but to the promise: §16 grants assimilation only 'to some extent', and §19, turning to the archetypal shadow, offers recognition and shock instead.

Follow the thread