Every Form You See

The Fountain Does Not Fail

Every form you see has its archetype in the placeless world;If the form perished, no matter, since its original is everlasting.Every fair shape you have seen, every deep saying you have heard,Be not cast down that it perished; for that is not so.Whereas the spring-head is undying, its branch gives water continually;Since neither can cease, why are you lamenting?Conceive the Soul as a fountain, and these created things as rivers:While the fountain flows, the rivers run from it.Put grief out of your head and keep quaffing this river-water;Do not think of the water failing; for this water is without end.From the moment you came into the world of being,A ladder was placed before you that you might escape.First you were mineral, later you turned to plant,Then you became animal: how should this be a secret to you?Afterwards you were made man, with knowledge, reason, faith;Behold the body, which is a portion of the dust-pit, how perfect it has grown!When you have travelled on from man, you will doubtless become an angel;After that you are done with this earth: your station is in heaven.Pass again even from angelhood: enter that ocean,That your drop may become a sea which is a hundred seas of ‘Omān.Leave this ‘Son,’ say ever ‘One’ with all your soul;If your body has aged, what matter, when the soul is young?

Dīvān-e Shams, ode XII · tr. R. A. Nicholson, 1898

The ‘Son’ of the last couplet is walad, and Nicholson's note sends it to his note on the Trinity and Qurʾān iv. 169 (4:171 in today's numbering, where God is far above having a son). His rhymed version in Appendix II says it outright: “‘The Son of God!’ Nay, leave that word unsaid, Say, ‘God is One’”.

Nicholson, Selected Poems (1898): note on XII. 11, p. 232 (“see VI. 13, note”); note on VI. 13, p. 217 (“alluding to the doctrine of the Trinity (see Kor. IV. 169, with Sale's note, v. 77)”); Appendix II (b), p. 344; Qurʾān 4:171


Every form has its archetype in the placeless world; the soul climbs from mineral to angel, then to the sea.

Ode XII, eleven couplets, printed here whole. Every form has its archetype in the placeless world, so no fair shape or deep saying is lost when it perishes: the Soul is a fountain and created things its rivers. From the sixth couplet the ode becomes a ladder — mineral, plant, animal, man with knowledge, reason and faith, then angel, then the ocean where the drop becomes “a hundred seas of ‘Omān” — and ends by telling the reader to leave “this ‘Son,’” and say “One”. Nicholson's note on couplets 6–10 quotes the Persian of the Masnavi passage that Whinfield renders “I died as inanimate matter and arose a plant” (Book III, p. 159). He followed the Leyden manuscript (L) for the Persian, which Rosenzweig's Auswahl also carries; he named it among three of the finest poems in his selection found in a single manuscript, and recast it as rhymed quatrains in Appendix II.

Light

It meets grief with metaphysics that stays tender: nothing fair you have seen or heard is lost while the spring that gave it runs, and an aging body is no loss “when the soul is young”.

Shadow

Nicholson followed one manuscript for the Persian, the Leyden copy of 851 A.H., and Rosenzweig's printed selection also carries the ode; Ibrahim Gamard lists the ode among seven of Nicholson's forty-eight that are not in the earliest manuscripts and are no longer considered Rūmī's.

Sources and verification5 sources · 3 links

Primary source

Scholarship

The tradition itself

Where this claim originates

Linked entries

  • Attributed toRūmīDisputed

    Printed as Rūmī's by Nicholson from the Leyden manuscript of 851 A.H. and Rosenzweig's selection; Ibrahim Gamard lists it among seven of Nicholson's odes not in the earliest manuscripts.

  • Part ofThe Dīvān-e Shams-e TabrīzīDisputed

    Ode XII of Nicholson's forty-eight selections from the Dīvān; on Gamard's report it is not in the text Furūzānfar built from the earliest manuscripts.

  • Derives fromReynold A. NicholsonAttested

    The English is Nicholson's 1898 prose; he also made the whole ode into rhymed quatrains, “Poor copies out of heaven's original”, in Appendix II.