The Druids

No Word of Their Own

No druid left a surviving word of his own: the white robe, oak and golden sickle are one paragraph of Pliny, and the triads, Awen and bardic circles sold as druidic wisdom were written by Iolo Morganwg himself between about 1790 and 1826.

The learned class of Iron Age Gaul and Britain: described only by outsiders, reinvented after 1700.


Caesar wrote the fullest ancient account while conquering the people he described: druids judged disputes, met yearly among the Carnutes, some trained twenty years, and held it wrong to write their teaching down, though they used Greek letters for accounts (De Bello Gallico VI.13–14, c. 51 BCE). Pliny supplies the white robe, the oak and the golden sickle (Natural History XVI.249, 77 CE); Tacitus has Suetonius Paulinus cut down the groves of Anglesey in 60 or 61 CE (Annals XIV.30). Every witness is Greek or Roman, and several draw on the lost Posidonius. Not one word by a druid survives, so the doctrine came later — Stonehenge made druidic by John Aubrey in manuscript, put in print by Stukeley in 1740, and the triads, the Awen rays and the bardic Gorsedd of 1792 from Iolo Morganwg, who wrote them himself.

Light

Even the hostile record credits them with judging disputes, and a discipline some stayed in twenty years, unwritten for Caesar's two reasons: to keep it from the crowd, and pupils from trusting writing over memory. The Druid Network registered as a religious charity in 2010.

Shadow

Caesar's wicker image of living men comes from the general prosecuting the war, and outside Strabo's Posidonian material it is attested nowhere. The silence that left it unanswerable invited Iolo Morganwg to write a druidic theology himself and pass it off as medieval Welsh manuscript.

Sources and verification10 sources · 7 links

Primary source

  • Tacitus, Annals XIV.30, 1937, Cited by book and chapter. Loeb Classical Library vol. V (Annals XIII-XVI), trans. John Jackson. Tacitus wrote c. 110-120 CE about events of 60 or 61 CE.The Roman assault on Mona (Anglesey) under Suetonius Paulinus and the felling of the groves sacred to their cults - black-robed women with dishevelled hair brandishing torches, and druids raising their hands to heaven pouring out imprecations. The chapter says the groves were cut down, not burnt. The last appearance of British druids in a narrative source close to the events.
  • Julius Caesar, De Bello Gallico VI.13-18, in John T. Koch with John Carey (eds), The Celtic Heroic Age, 4th ed., 2003, Cited by book and chapter, stable across editions. Caesar composed Book VI c. 52-51 BCE, describing the campaigns of 53 BCE.VI.13 for the annual assembly in the territory of the Carnutes and the report that the discipline was discovered in Britain; VI.14 for the training some stayed in twenty years, the refusal to commit the teaching to writing while using Greek letters for public and private accounts, the two reasons Caesar gives for that refusal - that the discipline should not be divulged and that pupils should not trust writing over memory - and the doctrine that souls do not die but pass from one to another; VI.16 for the figures of immense size, limbs woven of twigs, filled with living men and burnt. Cited as what a general wrote while conquering Gaul, never as a neutral record.
  • Pliny the Elder, Natural History XVI.249 and XXX.13, 2003, XVI.249 (chapter 95 in the older numbering) in Koch and Carey, The Celtic Heroic Age, 4th ed. (2003); Book XXX in the Loeb Classical Library, trans. W. H. S. Jones. The Natural History was presented to Titus in 77 CE.XVI.249 for the entire visual image of a druid - the priest in white, the oak, the golden sickle, the mistletoe caught in a white cloak, the two white bulls, the sixth day of the moon - which is one passage and the only ancient description of the rite. XXX.13 for Pliny's claim that the principate of Tiberius did away with the druids of Gaul.
  • Charity Commission for England and Wales, Decision on the application for registration of The Druid Network, 2010, Decision of 21 September 2010, after an application first refused in 2006That the Druidry practised by The Druid Network was held to be established for exclusively charitable purposes for the advancement of religion for the public benefit, and registered on that footing - the record behind this entry's statement about 2010. The decision concerns that one applicant, not Druidry at large, and the modern revival is distinct from the ancient office it is named for.

Scholarship

  • Ronald Hutton, Blood and Mistletoe: The History of the Druids in Britain, 2009, New Haven: Yale University PressThe separation of the little known about ancient druids from the great deal invented about them from the sixteenth century onward - Aubrey and then Stukeley on the stone circles, the Welsh revival, Iolo Morganwg's forgeries, the Gorsedd, the modern orders - and the demonstration that the stone circles were never theirs. The authority behind every sentence in this entry that says 'this is modern'.
  • Miranda Aldhouse-Green, Caesar's Druids: Story of an Ancient Priesthood, 2010, New Haven: Yale University PressThe archaeological side and its limits: what Iron Age ritual deposits, bog bodies and the Stanway 'doctor's' burial can and cannot be made to say about a priesthood that no surviving object names.

The tradition itself

  • Caesar, De Bello Gallico VI.14, on the druids' prohibition against committing their learning to writingThe esoteric reading given on this entry

Where this claim originates

  • William Stukeley, Stonehenge, a Temple Restor'd to the British Druids, 1740, London; with Abury, a Temple of the British Druids (1743). Free on the Internet Archive and at Project Gutenberg, ebook 61567.Cited for what Stukeley claimed in 1740 and 1743 and never as evidence: that Stonehenge and Avebury were druid temples. This is the printed source of an association now universal in popular belief. The attribution itself was John Aubrey's, proposed in the 'Templa Druidum' of the unpublished Monumenta Britannica (written c. 1663-93, not printed until 1980-82) which Stukeley had read; Stukeley is what carried it to the public. It was made about monuments raised two millennia before any surviving mention of a druid.
  • Iolo Morganwg (Edward Williams); ed. J. Williams ab Ithel, Barddas, 2 vols, 1862, Llandovery: Welsh MSS Society; free on the Internet ArchiveCited for what Iolo Morganwg (1747-1826) asserted and never as evidence about ancient druids: the Awen of three rays, the Gorsedd ritual, the circles of Annwn, Abred, Gwynfyd and Ceugant, and most of the 'druidic triads' still quoted as ancient Welsh wisdom. He wrote them himself and passed them off as medieval Welsh manuscripts; ab Ithel published them credulously after his death.

Further reading

  • John T. Koch (ed.), Celtic Culture: A Historical Encyclopedia, 5 vols, 2006, Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIOReference overview of the druids, the classical testimonia, the Gorsedd and the modern orders, with the print edition identified for each source.

Linked entries

  • CorrectsAwenA modern connection

    The three rays are the emblem people now put on the office, and they are Iolo Morganwg's: they travel with the Gorsedd he founded in 1792 and are set out in Barddas, published in 1862, thirty-six years after his death. No ancient source gives the druids a symbol at all.

  • Set againstOghamAttested

    Ogham survives as some four hundred cut stones carrying no doctrine; the druids survive as doctrine - Caesar's and Pliny's - carrying no object. The two meet only in medieval Irish fiction, where Tochmarc Etaine has a druid cut ogam on four yew wands to find a missing queen.

  • Set againstThe Greek Magical PapyriAttested

    The Egyptian papyri are practitioners writing for themselves - recipes, voces magicae, spells copied out for use - which is exactly the class of evidence the druids do not leave. Everything ancient said about them was written by Greeks and Romans, and the fullest account is the one the general conquering Gaul wrote.

  • Set againstOpón IfáA modern connection

    Both are dated from the outside — the Druids only by Greek and Roman writers, the tray by a German inventory of 1659 — but Ifá's corpus is still held and recited by living babaláwo.

  • Set againstThe AvestaAttested

    Caesar reported that the Druids held it wrong to commit their learning to writing, and none of it survives. The Zoroastrian priesthood also transmitted by memory for centuries — and then had an alphabet of some fifty letters built to catch the exact sound of what it said.

  • Set againstThe NornsA modern connection

    Both popular pictures were largely assembled after 1700, but the druidic picture was invented outright on a priesthood that left no word of its own, whereas the norns' is genuinely medieval and only its tidy division of time is modern.

  • Set againstVelesA modern connection

    The same shape twice: a thin ancient record written mostly by outsiders, and a large modern invention grown over it. Iolo Morganwg's papers, printed as Barddas in 1862, decades after his death, supplied the druids with a scripture they never had; the Vlesova kniga of 1957 did the same for Veles, and both are still quoted as ancient.